New York City Pizza - Bluffton

Always quick and friendly, lively atmosphere. Soups are delicious, pizza good big slices. Chicken Parm and pasta need a bit more care. Sometimes the chicken is hard and dry and the pasta over cooked. Other food selections are great!Food: 4/5

NYCP’s ingredients do not reflect the quality that their pricing reflects. Their cook on their pizzas has been extremely inconsistent over the past five years and most recently the bottom of the pizza was burnt. The center is overloaded with cheese and their is never enough sauce for the proper cheese/sauce ratio and the undercarriage can not support it and is extremely floppy. It’s better then the chains but again it lacks the quality to reflect its price.

Whether I’m eating the restaurant or getting food to go, the service is always outstanding.Pizzas to go are always piping hot. House salad is huge. Good selection of entrees. Smash burger and chicken Marsala are excellent. Cheers!Parking: Parking is fine…….restaurant shares parking lot with grocery store.

We love NYCP. It’s been our favorite since we lived here in 2016. And, we love it crispy and they always get that right. The Sicilian pie , sausage and pepperoni are our faves!Food: 5/5

Charge $24 for 2 slices of Supreme style pizza. They just put raw veggies on a slice of pre made pepperoni. They did not cook them .Confronted manager she said that was the price told her it was bad did not offer discount. Place is over priced little Ceasars quality. I am a chef also