Milk Can Diner - Greendale

The location in Greendale , WI is closed effective October 2023. The Muskego location is still open.

Service: Dine in Meal type: Dinner Price per person: $10–20 Food: 4 Service: 4 Atmosphere: 4

Food is good. But the portions are extremely small for the price. It's for the high end (price wise) customer. Not for everyone Price per person: $20–30

Breakfast took 1 hour 40 minutes. We requested our bill and it still took 15 minutes to get it, the waiter came and said I heard you want to pay twice, do you want any desert? For breakfast no, we want to leave if I had known it would take an additional 15 minutes I would have told the waiter. (I got my own box to speed things along) We were standing around and they didn't see us, my boyfriend overheard them say we left without paying. No we can't sit anymore. Then when he went in to pay the waiter said oh I thought you already paid. If I had the cash I would have just what bill was about and left. We will only do take out or get for wine bar in the future.

I want to like this place because the atmosphere is so inviting and the staff is exceptional. But the food we have tried has been subpar and the prices are high. Meatloaf sandwich was awful. Did not appear to have any beef in it, only filler. Seemed like tofu or something and it was gray and mushy. Chili was mediocre. Not enough beans and the taste was a little off. Burger wasn't as great as other folks have reported. Just average. The best part was the boozy shake: Brandy old fashioned was SO tasty. I might come back just for that, but probably nothing else.