Best Cookies Shop Nyc New York Bakery Cookies The Cookie Outlet

These cookies are the best I've ever had and always my go-to whenever I'm in town.

I absolutely adore this hidden gem of a store!! Not only do I purchase treats for myself, but I also send them as gifts. My oldest daughter moved to North Carolina with her family, and for some reason, they don't make rainbow cookies like they do here. I sent her family a 3-pound box for Christmas. The packaging was exceptional, as not a single cookie was broken when they arrived! I won't mention the name of the bakery her father recently visited in Levittown, but my daughter said the cookies were awful!! Thank you for putting smiles on my grandsons' faces with your delicious treats!! <3

We love the cookie outlet. Our favorite are the rainbow cookies. Nice and fresh.

After many years of going here to get cookies for special occasions, they have really disappointed us all. I purchased about 2 lbs of rainbow cookies, a package of Raspberry Finger cookies and marzipan. Prices were way up, but quality was way down. You could not even taste any almond flavor in the rainbow cookies. You would think with the high price increase they would at least keep the ingredients and recipe the same. No, they tasted so plain and everyone noticed. Also saw the same Raspberry Finger cookies in Stop and Shop costing much less. Factory outlet that charges more?! Will not be ripped off here ever again.

I purchased a 4 lb tray of rainbow cookies and a 4 lb tray of Italian cookies from this restaurant. The rainbow cookies were delicious, but I was disappointed with the Italian cookies. Even the guests at the party were surprised that there were no raspberry jelly filled cookies. The tray only contained chocolate chip, sprinkle, plain, and sesame cookies. I felt that they were not worth the money. I reached out to the company with a complaint, but unfortunately, I never received a response. It looks like I will have to find a new company to order from in the future.