Colandrea's Pizza King - Middletown

My wife and I visited Colandrias Pizza today. I had pre-ordered a half tray of meatballs to take home, which was a great deal at just $35 and came with garlic bread and three small loaves. We started with a slice of Grandma pizza as an appetizer, and it was absolutely incredible. For our main course, we had a seafood combo with Fra Diavolo sauce over linguine, which included garlic bread and a side salad, all for $21.99. It was delicious, and we couldn't finish it! I highly recommend Colandrias Pizza.

I absolutely adore their pizza! Even though I left the area 40 years ago, the first thing I do when I return to visit family is order a Colandrea veggie pizza. This time, I tried a half veggie and half chicken parm, and it was incredible. The crust is perfectly chewy, and the sauce is bursting with flavor. Living in the South, I can’t find pizza like this anywhere down there. Plus, it was ready in just 15 minutes! This is truly the best pizza in the area!

I was in town for business and ordered their wings. Their mild wing sauce is the best I've ever had. I just wish I didn't live five hours away!

This was my first time ordering food after moving to the area, and I have to say, this pizza was fantastic. The crust had a perfect texture, and the toppings—clearly, someone put a lot of care into them. They didn't hold back at all, and I must say, the pizza looked absolutely amazing. I've definitely found my new favorite pizza place! It looked so delicious that I completely forgot to take a picture before diving in.

In comparison to other pizza places in the area, most menu items here are priced about $1-2 higher. However, the pizza is quite delicious and definitely stands out from the competition. On the downside, I wasn't a fan of their chicken fingers.