Antonio's Cupcake Factory - New Windsor

I have ordered every single birthday cake and birthday cupcakes from Antonio’s since 2017, I am pleasantly surprised every time. Delicious flavor, moist cake, and I always receive compliments. Highly recommend the pink velvet and the strawberry buttercream. Chocolate truffle is my personal favorite. It is always an easy ordering experience, the staff is always friendly, and they make a quality product.

Best cake I've had. Asked for a baby shark themed cake for my son's 1st birthday and it was beautiful. It was a chocolate cake with cookies and cream filling and it tasted amazing. This will be my new go to for cakes!

Honestly, just no. I came here to get some last minute cupcakes for a friends bday and was immediately turned off by firstly the RUDE service by who I’m going to assume is the owner, and secondly it was giving yard sale cup cake and wasn’t very clean and by not very clean I mean filthy… there’s a girl I’ve hated since kindergarten and I wouldn’t even subject that monster to one of their stale looking cupcakes.

I have been ordering cakes from Antonio's for several years. His cakes are so delicious, the flavor is always there and never dry. I even ordered a gluten free cake for my daughters communion and nobody was able to tell the difference. He is very easy to communicate with and will definitely guide you if you are not sure what do to or are indecisive like myself. We particularly like the buttercream and the chocolate ganache. The best part is that his cakes are reasonably priced! You will pay more if you are having custom fondant pieces made as he has someone who comes in that charges him by the hour. All of my guests have really enjoyed his cakes and I enjoy telling them where I ordered from. A wonderful local family business to support! Thank you for always doing such an amazing job. This review was well beyond over due.

What a gem! Had a strawberry shortcake made for a coworker. Everyone agreed it was one of the best cakes they've ever had. Texture was so light it was like eating a cloud, and sugar level was just right, not overly sweet like so many. Phenomenal. Customer service was also top notch. Would highly recommend.