Baldie's Pizzeria

My sons looooove the Buffalo wings from here!!! Always a hit.

I gave 4 stars 6 years ago. Now, far away from there, i'm missing that steak'n'cheese badly and came here to rate this place correctly.

The boneless buffalo tenders were over cooked and we couldn't eat them

I’m a long time resident of Bridgewater. I’ve been ordering from Baldie’s for years. In the past four years or so they have been rather hit or miss. Tonight was a miss. I ordered a large cheese pizza, Medium meat lovers and a large order of buffalo chicken tenders. You can see that the “buffalo “ chicken tenders in the picture are simply just tenders with some sauce slathered on top. Not very appealing. I could’ve done that myself. The meat lovers pizza was also very inconsistent as far as crust to actual topping ratio. One side of the pizza had half crust half toppings and other side was more normal. Very lopsided. I’d like to see them step up their game and get back to where they were years ago with consistent quality.

Visited the Bridgewater location for 2 salads. Food was good. Questioned the price which was almost double what the menu listed. I was told that the menu is old. How old is it? The cost according to the menu was $9.00 each yet I was charged $14.96 each. While they have a handwritten sign that says prices may vary, is a 66% increase a “vary”? Get new menus with the correct prices. When someone calls in an order, give them the total like every other phone order.I gave a 2 star because the food was good. Service very poor. Will no longer visit this place.