The Cotter Pin, Llc - Sparta

Decided to try this place for the first time a few days ago. The exterior is inviting. The interior decor is updated and clean. The service was great. My big hubby ordered the personal pizza. Wished the server had said something that it would probably be too small for him, as it's a great kids pizza but not for a large, adult man. The pizza was good but the sauce had an off taste but still not bad. He could have eaten 3 of those pizzas. I had the chicken salad wrap that was good but there just wasn't much filling. However, when we got the bill and it was only $20 I understood why. Very affordable, small portions. Sadly, we both left feeling a bit hungry but we will go back. Next time we'll just order more food, especially with those prices. I've never seen a refillable soda at $1.50 in a few years. Excellent prices!!

Moved to the area a year ago and have felt there aren't many options for good food without going into LaX. On a whim we decided to try some takeout from The Cotter Pin. It did not disappoint! We ordered a personal pepperoni pizza, 12 wings, the loaded tots, and the bacon cheeseburger mac and cheese. I had a couple drinks while waiting at the bar for my order. Drinks were delicious and were just the right strength. The kitchen was closing in an hour on a Wednesday evening. The last of a larger group was leaving. Cool place. definitely not a country dive bar. Clean and modern. When I got the food home, the pizza was simple, cracker thin crust. 7/10 The loaded tots were as expected but a little dry. There could've been more beer cheese sauce. 6/10 The bacon cheeseburger Mac and cheese was very good and creamy. It's only topped with the meat and cheese not mixed in busy still very good. 8/10 And the surprise was the wings. Huge!! $1 wings on Wednesday (not sure if this is offered every week) but I felt it was a value for the meaty juicy wings. I got them in buffalo which was creamy and not too spicy, garlic parm which was a pretty standard sauce, nothing to say here, and the jerk dry seasoning which was good but wish there was more on it. Overall the wings were a 9/10. I do have to say that the service was prompt and friendly. I'll definitely return!

This place is offers good quality homemade food!! I love the fact that there is no fryer. A very welcome change to the usual local menu. In addition, very welcoming staff and friendly owner. Glad we came and will definitely be back!

Prime rib melt was delicious as well as the Sangria! Great atmosphere and friendly bartenders/servers. Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5

Service: Dine in Meal type: Dinner Price per person: $10–20 Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5