Grace At The Carnegie Inn

Service: Dine in Meal type: Lunch Price per person: $20–30 Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5

A beautiful evening, from beginning to end. Top notch service. Kind and attentive staff. Extremely clean and well maintained/well appointed surroundings. Very comfy seating. Generously sized tables that don’t get crowded or cluttered. Fresh flowers. Lovely waitress with great recommendations and humor. Delicious and exceptionally well made food. Highly recommend the filet dinner and the chocolate variations dessert. Well worth the money. Easily the very best restaurant in the region. I will be back over and over again.

My favorite place for great food and excellent drinks. Service: Dine in Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5

We were there for 2 hours, watching people that were seated after us come and go. We had reservations and were on time! We waited nearly 20 minutes for anyone to come to the table and get our drink orders. We waited nearly and hour for our salads after that. At an hour and 45 minutes, we flagged down a waitress and asked for our meals to go because we were over it. No one checked on us or explained why there was a delay. No one explained why other people had multiple course meals and paid their checks while we were still waiting for salads. No one apologized or made any effort to create a fine dining experience for us. We were essentially invisible. It was beyond aggravating to see people on either side of us being waited on, with no check ins, offers for refilled drinks, or any communication whatsoever. We paid $200 for an anniversary dinner that we ended up eating at home, tired and cranky. The food was quite good but very overpriced and the service was absolutely terrible. There are other far more reasonably priced places to enjoy a romantic meal with excellent service and atmosphere.

We waited years to visit Grace (due to remodeling). We heard it was spectacular. We were very disappointed. We weren't asked for our drink order for 40 minutes after being seated while other tables who came in after received drinks and appetizers before we even placed our drink order. I ordered a Ceasar Salad, which I do often, and it was in the lower 25% of all Ceasar Salads I have had. Unfortunately, we were all rather disappointed. There were a few pretty good dishes. But, overall no where near the hype or the cost.