The Seafood Shop - WAINSCOTT

We had some of the best halibut EVER from the Wainscott Seafood Shop last night. Furthermore, the counter help really worked with us to trim the filets properly, and get the portion size right so our recipe could go off without a hitch. Bravo, team!

They charge $30 for a rabbit portion of guacamole. Just let that sink in. Talk about price gouging. Jeez Louise

$30 side of Guacamole? The price gouging is outrageous.

I have been a customer for 35+ years and have been 100% satisfied in every way.The best seafood, produce but most importantly…the BEST customer service from the entire team.“There are many places to shop for seafood…but only ONE Seafood Shop!”Support our local family businesses.

Spectacular Seafood…Exceptional Staff…Tremendous Value!!!The Seafood Shop is a MUST for those who live in the Hamptons (although you probably know this already) and especially those like us who visit the Hamptons periodically and want to get the highest quality meal for a tremendous value served up by a super accommodating staff! There honestly isn’t the need to go out to fancy restaurants because The Seafood Shop prepares out of this world made to order meals that are both plentiful but most importantly SUPER DELICIOUS! We had grilled Halibut with two sides the past two days that was cooked to perfection! Our compliments to the chef as it was honestly THE BEST Halibut we have EVER had…light and white and flaky delectable! Onion rings, waffle cut fries(extra crispy) and fried veggies as the sides garnished with lettuce leaf, huge tomato slice and a wedge of lemon…we couldn’t finish it all as the halibut portion and sides were so plentiful! And what’s incredible is that for two meals it costs only $47 including tax! We challenge anyone to find this kind of quality and value anywhere! Thanks to owner Colin and our new friend, Andrew, who made sure our orders were perfect we will continue to plan our meals around The Seafood Shop each and every day we are in the Hamptons. Once you try it we’re sure you will agree. Bon Appetit!