Allendale Steakhouse

Rated 4.5 out of 5 stars, I dined at this restaurant for dinner on a weekend. While the restaurant parking is limited, there is street parking available. It is a BYOB establishment with a liquor store conveniently located across the street. Reservations are strongly advised as it can get busy. The service was decent. I opted for the Porterhouse steak, which was excellent and I would definitely order it again. The price point is reasonable for the top-notch quality of the steak. It might just be the best steak I have ever had in the area.

The food at this restaurant was delicious and the portion sizes were generous. The establishment was clean and the wait staff was friendly. However, the service did not meet expectations. We had to request refills for our water glasses and empty dishes were not promptly removed from the table. We found ourselves having to ask for everything we needed, rather than being checked on by the wait staff. Overall, the service could have been more attentive.

This restaurant is one of the top steakhouses in New Jersey, possibly the best. The service and food are both excellent. The fact that it's BYOB is a bonus.

Great steaks. Quality you'd get at some of the top steak places in NYC. We we're a party of 6 guys and got the aged porterhouse for 5. It was the perfect amount in addition to the sides we ordered. The crab cake sides were also excellent. BYOB is a bonus!

Ate there last night. Five couples. Have dined there many times. Both my wife and I are certain that our dinner last night was the best dinner we've had in town in 34 years. I had the 28 oz. bone-in sirloin with the wedge salad. My wife had the boneless sirloin with the chopped salad. The other couples felt the same way. Already looking forward to my next meal there.