Johnny's New York Style Pizza - Athens

Exceptional place and food was awesome, atmosphere great. One of our favorite places definitely

We ordered the family deal today. All of it was absolutely AWFUL! The two salads COMBINED was barely enough to feed one person, the garlic knots were burnt and had all the garlic in the bottom of the tin and nothing on the actual knots themselves, the pizza was laughably over cooked as if someone did it on purpose to see if we'd say anything. I ordered a small pizza here yesterday and it was awesome! Today we had family over and ordered this for the football game and all had to eat somewhere else after! That should never have been allowed to be put together to actually be given to a paying customer. We used to order here very often. We'll never come back, purely because if you think this is acceptable to serve to someone (you could tell everything was burnt and the salad was half made just by GLANCING) then obviously you could care less about the customer that pays you money and there's no telling where else you lack quality and service. Only reason this place gets even one star is because i cannot give them zero stars and leave a warning for other potential customers. EDIT Received an email from the assistant manager Tanner apologizing and offering to comp the same order should we choose to return. We gave it another shot today and it was amazing. They apologized again a few times when we went in to pick up the order and showed us the food prior to leaving. It was all made exactly how johnnys typically does it and it was fantastic! Complete 180 from our previous experience and we will be SURE to return! Thank you guys!

Best pizza and best service. Love that place. Wish I could eat there everyday

So good. So so good. The lasagna was the bomb. Krissa was an excellent server!

We love Johnny's Pizza! it was hot and delicious. We like the atmosphere, plus it's so close to home.