Lefty's Tavern - Barnegat

Beautiful place! We ordered to-go twice from here, and it was super easy. We didn't have to leave the car. The food was fantastic. The only complaint was that we were not given anything to eat with, but it was mostly my fault for not asking.

Nestled in the heart of New Jersey, Lefty 's Tavern is a true gem that combines a warm and inviting ambiance with a delightful menu that caters to all taste buds. From the moment I stepped inside, I knew I was in for a memorable dining experience. As I perused the menu, I couldn 't help but notice their soup selection, which seemed perfect for the chilly evening. Intrigued, I ordered their Creamy Tomato Basil Soup. It arrived with a garnish of fresh basil, and as soon as I took the first spoonful, I was transported to a world of comfort. The velvety texture and the harmonious blend of flavors were simply divine. But what made my visit truly special was the outstanding service provided by our waitress, Sarah. Her warm smile and attentive nature immediately made us feel at home. Sarah was incredibly knowledgeable about the menu and was more than happy to help us make the perfect choices for our meal. Throughout our dining experience, Sarah 's attentive service was a true highlight. She made sure our glasses were always filled and checked on us with impeccable timing, ensuring we had everything we needed to enjoy our time at Lefty 's Tavern. To accompany our meal, Sarah recommended trying their signature Lefty 's Lemonade, a refreshing and delightful concoction that perfectly complemented the flavors of the dishes. In conclusion, Lefty 's Tavern in New Jersey is a culinary haven for those seeking a cozy and memorable dining experience. Their Creamy Tomato Basil Soup was a comforting delight, and Sarah 's exceptional service added a personal touch that made our visit all the more enjoyable. Whether you 're looking for a comforting bowl of soup or a satisfying meal in a warm atmosphere, Lefty 's Tavern is the place to be.

Sat at the bar and had dinner there. Drinks were tasty and the food was really good. The Manhatten chowder was on point and the steak made perfectly (medium rare). The bartender was friendly and had a good sense of humor. Will go back.

We love coming here whenever we're at the Shore...generous portions, always hot and flavorful...and we love having tablecloths! I had the shrimp and scallop medley… The size of the shrimp and scallops were enormous...You won't be disappointed!

Worst service I've ever received in any restaurant, EVER ! Our server didn't get one thing right from the start. 15 minutes to get to table, took drink order, forgot drink order. I had to go to bar. Then on refill, he never asked what I was drinking and never returned to ask. Half hour just to take our dinner order, another half hour never received our salad. Then 30 more minutes brought our dinners, oops forgot salads. Sent dinners back. Then when salads came, not by him by the way,and wrong dressings. Then completely wrong dinners delivered to our table. We both ordered Ribeyes and were serve fish.I'll spare you all the rest of the details. Went to talk to the manager twice. Total disaster. Too bad because food was good when we finally got what we ordered. Two and a half hour ordeal. Never again!