Milk And Sugar Cafe - Bay Shore

Cosy restaurant!. Another type of restaurant, with couches and low tables and traditional seating. as in a comfortable living room. soups are phenomenal, such as grilled cheese and bacon. great salads, pleasant staff and many baked goods.

Great. Pricey, but, great... the menu has cut off a bit since I was last there, but overall a plus.

Good food, great atmosphere. While eating here is very good (although a little on the expensive side), the atmosphere is amazing. Where else you can sit on a couch, play some chess, and drink one of a selection of a few dozen specialties teas or a variety of flavored coffee from a cup the size of a soup boiler?

I love this place, but try to get a table on a Fri. or Sat. night. No reservations are taken and you can wait, sometimes out in the cold rain for over an hour...

Milk and Sugar Café might sound like just a tea or coffee shop but don't let the name fool you like it fooled us. Initially we were just going to stop in for coffee after lunch until we saw photos of the food online, so we decided to make this our lunch spot for the day.