Aj's Pizza - BAYFIELD

Yum! Though the gi-normous pizza slices $5! What a deal! looked right-out-of-the-oven delicious, we opted for meatball and turkey bacon sandwiches. The turkey bacon was fresh, loaded with all ingredients including field greens and custom made with jalapeño. Just right. The meatballs were spicy and tasted home made. It includes melty mozzarella cheese, red onions again, just the right amount for flavor and texture but not to overwhelm and flavorful marinara on the side. Both sandwiches were on delicious, firm on the outside and soft on the inside, fresh-tasting flatbread and were generous enough for two meals. Side salad was also generous enough to split and again, fresh and loaded with crunchy, tasty croutons. The mom and pop type store our favorite type had a rush of business just after we ordered but it did not negatively affect our order in any way. We also got hand-scooped ice cream again, generous portions which we have yet to indulge in. Highly recommend this business for tourists and home towers alike.

I love Aj's Pizza! They do not only offer hunger quenching meals for an affordable prize in the form of pizza, but they also serve wings, fries, sandwiches and more. There is so many options to choose from and on top of that all there is ice cream, who doesn't love ice cream. Aj's is also a large contributor to Bayfield's community; just stepping inside will illuminate this fact. If there were more stars to give I would.

Ugh! This is definitely not good pizza. Go to Home Slice in Durango or Eepa's in Bayfield. Feeling cheap? Just get a frozen one at the grocery store much better tasting than a $22 large pepperoni here!

Ordered 2 sausage pizzas tonight...they looked like the delivery guy dropped them...all the cheese and topping were on one side. The dough was raw...they were watery and greasy. Definately not worth the price.! You're better off making a frozen pizza instead

Their Alfredo pizza is so delicious. Sometimes they can be a bit slow but if you call ahead, it's literally no big deal.