Anthony's Kitchen Cocktails - Bellmore

Great food. Great atmosphere, menu on point. Renovations look great. Highly recommend.

Loved the original Anthony's, comfortable, great food and service. New Anthony's beautifully done, very modern. The problem was that we couldn't talk among 4 people, music was way too loud. Very busy so noisy, server had joked she needed to use hand signals to talk.

We had been to this place a few years ago. The atmosphere was cozy and the food was good. We went recently for a friend's birthday with 3 other couples. We didn't realize it had been renovated and I have to say we did not enjoy the ambiance at all. The cozy, Tuscan vibe was gone. It is very modern looking, which was fine. The worst part about it was the incredibly loud 90s club music. It was ridiculous. We were looking to have a nice night with a few drinks, good food, and to catch up with friends, but nobody could hear each other speak. When we asked if they could turn down the music a bit, they said they couldn't. It was really disappointing to have to scream at your friend sitting across the table, just so they could hear what you were saying. They service was slow as well. The food is still pretty good, but for the ambiance alone, I will not be going back.

Our granddaughter's family party in honor of her christening at Anthony's Kitchen Cocktails couldn't have been more perfect. The attention to detail by Anthony and his staff was on point!! They didn't miss a trick. The food was by far some of the best dishes in NY and I don't say that lightly (I'm a self-proclaimed restaurant food critic, lol). If you are looking for a really great dining experience, make plans to dine at Anthony's. He cares about his customers, and loves what he does....it shows in every bite. Promise!!! Reservations do fill up quickly, so don't wait.

The food is great here. I think it was a bit pricy, but that's me. They make a great cocktail and have professional staff.