The Corey Creek Inn - BLUE POINT

My husband and I went for a date night on Valentine's Day. It took 15 minutes for a server to come take our drink order because evidently there was a difference of opinion on who our server was! In fact, a table that was seated five minutes after us were served first. Everything on the menu sounded wonderful. We started with the Brie En Croute and the grilled oysters. The Brie was cold and the grill oysters came minus the charred bread that was advertised on the menu. My husband ordered the meatloaf Wellington which he said was good but lukewarm and I ordered the pistachio crusted lamb chops which were not cooked to my medium order specifications and we're also cold. We will not be back!

Great food, nice cozy atmosphere, and excellent service. Something for all tastes. Not inexpensive, but well worth it. The live music also adds to the fun and unique flavor of the restaurant.

We came for a nice New Years Eve dinner and they let us order off the menu. We weren’t up for the price fixed menu, just wanted a quiet dinner. The owners are friendly and the food was outstanding. Nice way to end the year. We had the seafood Fra Diavolo and the osso bucco. Very nice. We look forward to coming back!

Good food but not good enough for the price. I had a great waitress though

I can’t make an assessment because when I arrived at 10mins before my reservation in the restaurant, I discovered a handwritten note that was wrapped in the door: “ closed until NOT furtherICE”. while I understand that problems are created and restaurants must close for emergencies, I find it inconceivable that with today's technology, a reservation for a very important event in someone's life (my wife birthday) cannot be marked in any way and the reservation either not allowed, or at least to the individual who made the and let them know his plans for the evening have changed. it was a surprising birthday dinner that was ruined as a result. now I have to deal with living social who liked to take my money for an dinner that never happened. I'm not happy, is an understatement.