Ootoya Times Square - Broad Channel

We ordered the set menus… well i guess there were no other options as we arrived too early for dinner… everything was really good… i ordered the unagi set… definitely the most tender unagi i have ever tasted… also ordered sake flights which were refreshing… really worth the visit… the place was packed and we were lucky we got in a bit early…

I heard so many good things about Ootoya. Wait was for an hour. Food was good and the service was good. I will come back!

Decided to come here for a quick dinner before a show at The Town Hall. We were seated at the counter and there was no wait for a seat despite it being close to dinnertime on a Sunday. I got the Katsu Don and the Matcha Anmitsu for dessert. The Katsu Don was alright, the cutlet was somewhat juicy, but I've had better elsewhere. The sauce was fruity and tart, which I am not a fan of, but I know this is the traditional Katsu sauce flavor, so it's just a matter of personal preference. I much rathe … – show

The service was exceptional, friendly, and welcoming. However, I feel like the food is overpriced for an okay portion. I ordered an egg appetizer, but it tasted SUPER fishy even tho it’s just eggs. The sashimi tasted very fishy and not too fresh. However, I did enjoy the sushi and it’s different adding crunchy rice, but it was a bit overwhelming. It came with 11 pieces of sushi and the price is a bit high. I would recommend coming here to try their sushi because it’s a different, but most of the … – show

The beef nabe is good. If you guys go to there, you must try this one!