Papa Kelsey's Pizza Subs - Buhl

Whenever I go to Papa Kelsey, I always order the Italian combo sandwich in the 16-inch size. I usually share it with someone else, as it’s not quite enough to fill you up completely, but it's perfect for keeping both of us satisfied until our next meal. If you attempt to eat the whole sandwich on your own, you might not need to eat again for the rest of the day! The sandwich is delicious, loaded with meat, and if you share, it’s quite affordable. I've been enjoying these subs here for a long time, and the quality has remained consistently excellent. Their oven-baked sandwiches are among the best around. Each sandwich comes with a small bag of classic potato chips. The restaurant's interior is very stylish with a beautiful modern design. I highly recommend Papa Kelsey!

Papa Kelsey's in Buhl, Idaho is fantastic! Tonya is truly exceptional at her job. She works incredibly hard and strives for perfection in everything she does. I placed an order tonight, and as always, it exceeded my expectations! She deserves a huge shoutout for her efforts. Employees like her are a tremendous asset to your company, especially since they're so hard to find these days! - Area Motta

I really enjoyed their subs, and the pizza was great as well.

Papa Kelsey's has good sandwiches but you barely get meat on the triple meat without adding more. Just adding jalapeños to it, its a $15 sandwich. I ordered 2 sandwiches and some spicy fries for my son. It's $37 and some change, plus the extra 3% for debit card use. Ridiculous! I could go to subway and get my husband and I sandwiches for $22. Sad thing is it is better than Subway. Quick food isn't worth it in a pinch anymore.

First time here! The dining area was very clean and the staff were friendly. We had 8 of us and the food was done very timely. This the 6 Malibu Chicken with chips. It was yummy!