Carters Family Restaurant - Carlyle

The breakfast at this restaurant is fantastic and very generous. It comes highly recommended by the locals. However, the noise level can be quite high due to the concrete walls.

My experience at this restaurant was a mix of good and bad. I received a burnt pizza that they refused to refund because they claimed it was just slightly overcooked. When I ordered takeout for my family of six, they gave us a pizza that was a size smaller than what we ordered and did not correct the mistake. It seems like mistakes in the kitchen are common here. I would recommend dining in rather than getting takeout, but be prepared for slow service as they are short-staffed and may not promptly refill your drinks. The waiters are constantly on the go.

The pizza at this restaurant is fantastic and reasonably priced. They offer an excellent variety on their menu with plenty of options to choose from. On Sundays, they also have a brunch buffet at a great price.

We thought they could make a decent meal, but we were surprised by our experience. the waitress was completely in order, but the veggie omelette they presented to my wife was the hands down the worst omelette I had ever had the dissatisfaction of tasting in all my life. have they ever been in a omelet with soggy vegetables and absolutely zero flavor? we did it.and we refused to touch it again after our first bite. what is even worse after the owner let me know how terrible this is eating several times and in many more detailed ways he looked at me as if I was crazy and insisted that all the others eat it like that. each restaurant owner would know that it is not possible to treat a customer. I don't care if you've been here for decades, your amateur. either everyone in carlyle has no taste, or this guy is delirical. he refused to take the omelette from our order, and he has earned hard. Hold the towel bud.

Me and my wife thought this would be a typical mediocre but edible restaurant so we gave it a shot. Boy were we wrong about our initial opinion.The waitress was fine, but the food was horrendous. Have you ever had an omelette with watered down bad eggs, soggy vegetables and a general taste of bland dog food? We did! You can also tell that their veggies on the side order of burgers etc are those frozen bags of peas carrots and corn you buy at grocery stores. Not cool. What's worse is that after informing the manager in numerous detailed ways of our distaste for the food he just looked at us as if we were completely wrong and kept adamantly saying this is the way he's been cooking it for years and refused to take the dishes off our order. Either all the people of Carlyle have no tastebuds or this guy is delirious. The absolute worst customer service I have ever had the displeasure of witnessing. I don't care if you've been in the food biz for years, you're still an amateur. Hang up the towel bud.