Godfather's Pizza - Cayuga

This is the second time I've had a bad experience with Godfather's Pizza. The pizza was undercooked and the service was terrible. The dough was still raw on top of the pizza. The girl who took my order had a bad attitude and even hung up on me. I would not recommend ordering from here again. Save your money or go to McDonald's instead.

We always enjoy Godfathers Pizza every time we order from there. The staff is friendly as well. We always come back for more. Our go-to is usually the Manager's Special whenever we're on our way to the trailer.

The pizza at this restaurant is not worth the high price. We placed our order online after receiving a flyer in the mail, requesting chicken on both pizzas as advertised. However, when we arrived to pick up our order, we were surprised by the extra charge for the chicken topping that was not mentioned on the flyer. Additionally, the cheese breadsticks did not come with marinara sauce, and the quality of the food was subpar with burnt areas and incorrect toppings. Overall, the cost does not justify the quality of the food, and we would recommend trying other pizza places in Caledonia or Dunnville instead.

Good overall Pizza more toppings would be nice getting a little skimpy but the taste is wonderful love Tuesday night cheap pizzas great for the budget

Probably the best pizza in the world. Slices or full pizza you can get it all. Friendly and cheap to eat.