The Bagelry - Cedar Knolls

After going to the Bagelry for close to a year now, I think it’s time we find a new spot. We usually get our bagels toasted and have consistently been getting burnt bagels..this was the worst one yet!! It is completely unacceptable, I don’t know how they can serve a bagel like this. If you like burnt bagels..this is your place!!

Some how they keep messing up cooking bacon when the bosses aren’t around. 20 minute wait for side bacon that was undercooked greasy and soggy. Bacon shouldn’t flop around like when is taken out of the package

Just takes entirely too long for a toasted bagel and cream cheese. Every time I’ve gone same result. Waiting while they cook a family of 5 breakfast sandwiches. How bout someone on bagels only? Just a thought

Really fresh bagels and awesome flavors of cream cheese.

Good lunch sandwiches, but this is a bagel place. Bagels are a plus! Crunchy outside and soft inside. Without toasting. Chocolate chip bagels!