Chatham Penny Candy Store

Charming little candy shop in a small town with delicious fudge and a decent selection of ice cream. The owner was very friendly. Please note, they only accept cash.

I'm so glad we visited this lovely spot! They have incredible ice cream and a gorgeous selection of desserts and fudge.

Fun little spot from Main Street in downtown Chatham where you can get all kinds of candy and saltwater taffy through the pound. Bring the whole family here and go to the selection. They also had sweets I had never heard of, and also served ice cream. Only cash.

Great business with a wide variety of options. Prices are quite reasonable. The taffy is absolutely delicious!

Had ice cream cones. Flavors were delicious, service was excellent. The variety of penny candy was incredible!