Tottenville Bagels - City of New York

Tottenville Bagels is my favorite deli on Staten Island because it offers some unique items I really love, like Tiramisù in a glass, orange-strawberry-banana juice, and the spiciest buffalo wings on the island. As a little inside joke, I used to call it Hot BS Bagels because many of the letters on their sign were unlit. The interior is quite small, but its location is excellent, right at the corner of Page and Amboy Road. I've also enjoyed their Nutella breadsticks and various juices. Ultimately, Tottenville Bagels is the only deli I go out of my way to visit because they have amazing exclusive products that I enjoy so much that I'm always happy to make the trip just to stock up.

This is a wonderful spot for breakfast, but I don’t like it when my eggs are brown. I usually have to request that they prepare them white, yellow, and fluffy.

The bagels were fresh and delicious, offering a wide range of flavors and toppings. The staff was friendly and efficient, and the prices were quite reasonable. However, the seating area felt a bit cramped and could have been cleaner. Additionally, during peak hours, the service was somewhat slow, making it challenging to get in and out quickly.

I have been a patron of this store for over 20 years. To be more precise, use to go here all the time about 10 years ago. My office changed locations so went less frequently over the years. Just recently I am doing some work in the area and have been going to them daily again. I am not sure of anyones names but literally every single person I deal with is helpful, acts courteous, and is always pleasant to me. While there, many customers came in, and the employees greeted them with their first name, Good morning, and before the customer could even speak they knew the order and just confirmed. I see this every time I go here. I am in this store in the morning hours never the afternoon or evenings. I do order different things from a breakfast platter to a plain bagel with cream cheese. Not a coffee drinker so cant comment on that. The food has always been very good. I highly recommend them.

Much love to this place but the prices are getting out of hand now, bec and a drink cost about 13$ thats crazy