All Star Pizza Italian - Coconut Creek

Always a wonderful experience! I love my pizza extra crispy, and they're always happy to customize it just the way I like. Many locals seem to prefer a softer crust, but even when they don't cook it longer, it still holds up well. Their specialty pizzas are fantastic too; the ricotta and garlic white pizza was exceptional. It’s clear that they take great pride in the dishes they serve.

The owners, Kelly and her husband, are fantastic! I visited for an appointment and had the chance to try some of their food. They offer outstanding customer service and are incredibly friendly and courteous. The pizza was absolutely delicious. You definitely won't be disappointed!

I've been a regular at this restaurant for years, but I've noticed a gradual decline in quality. I recently ordered a few pizzas for a small gathering, and when I got home, they appeared to be premade and simply reheated. All three pizzas were stale, old, and burnt. Unfortunately, this isn't my first unpleasant experience here, but it will certainly be my last. Given the rising prices and the cost of everything, including pizza, there are much better options out there where you can spend your money and enjoy better food!

They informed me it would take another 30 minutes. With a group of hungry kids waiting, I asked if they could expedite my order. I requested sausage and pepperoni on the pizza. They inquired if I wanted to order another pizza, but I declined, explaining that the family meal already included a cheese pizza and asked if they could simply add the toppings. Instead of understanding, they told me that would raise the price. Even after I explained that my original pizza hadn’t even been put in the oven and was already 20 minutes past the promised time, I got a "I'll speak to the manager" response. There was no apology or any sign of empathy; I was just treated like another order. Eventually, another employee came over and mentioned it would cost an additional $7 for the extra toppings, and I decided to forgo that. It was simply not worth it, especially since I didn’t want to give them any more of my money. So, here I am, waiting for a pizza I ordered an hour ago, while the kids are still hungry. If I hadn’t already paid, I would have left without hesitation. This restaurant clearly doesn’t value its customers. Mistakes can happen, but it’s how a business handles those mistakes that really defines them. I can’t comment on the food itself since I still haven’t received any, but I definitely won’t be returning.

The food was fantastic! The atmosphere is charming, and our server was incredibly friendly. My sister and I ordered the Alfredo pasta, which was excellent. It came with a side of garlic knots that were delightful, soft, and fresh. I was truly impressed and happy that I decided to come here!