Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza - Commack

I visited this restaurant for the first time and ordered 12 slices of pizza with pepperoni and a Diet Coke with lemon. There were plenty of tables available and there was music playing in the background.

The food has always been good but the way they resolved a mistake with an online order left a lot to be desired. I used their website to place a takeout order. When I got home I realized 1 of the 4 items ordered was missing. It took 10 mins on the phone to get them to refund my credit card (they initially offered a credit towards a future online order). The manager never got on the phone and the amount refunded didn't include the tax I paid on the missing item. Poor service all around.

I absolutely adore this restaurant! It's the ideal spot to catch a game. The food is consistently delicious and affordable. The wait staff is friendly and the bartender mixes a fantastic cosmo!

Stopped here to try the pizza. We also grabbed wings . The pizza is served nicely with a hearty portion for 3 if you split it. The wings are large and juicy , I recommend you ask for well done for a toastier wing. Tried the Carnivori thick cut pepperoni, Italian sausage, baby meatballs and smoky bacon Fuhgeddaboudit. The place is spacious and great for groups, Stop by , grab a fire coal pizza and a cold Peroni you will be pleasantly surprised!

The Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza location at this shopping center is excellent. I always make sure to stop by for their delicious meatball sandwich, which puts a twist on traditional Italian fare by adding hot peppers on panini bread instead of a white roll. The manager and staff are efficient and know my order well, always providing a satisfying experience. They even anticipate my preferences, like removing the hard-to-open bottle top from my Aqua Panna spring water without me asking. The loyalty program is a nice touch, and I especially enjoy the free birthday pizza. The cozy ambiance with plenty of natural light makes me feel at ease. I highly recommend this Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza location and look forward to bringing my friends here in the future.