Carelli's Pizzeria Pasta - Craig

This may be the best pizza i’ve ever eaten. would definitely overeat here again!

We ordered at the counter from a chalkboard on the wall. We were offered other dishes that were not on the board, too. We were told to order, get our own drinks, and have a seat. Our food was delivered to our table. We went to the counter to pay. 4 adults, a 6 yo and 8 yo was $150. When we realized there were no prices listed we became a little concerned. The pizza stromboli were amazing! The place was really cute. We saw a lot of pizza take outs while we were there. We would definitely order pizza again if we lived in Craig!

If you’re looking for good pizza in Craig, CO you have to go to Carelli’s. They make excellent NY style pizza. I was skeptical at first looking for good pizza during our stay in Craig and was pleasantly surprised by just how good the pizza was. Some of the best that I’ve ever had! The owners are super friendly and we had a fun time chatting with them while we were waiting for our take out.

Wow! Pleasantly surprised that such a tiny town has such a legit pizzeria. A bit of a wait, but definitely worth it.

Awesome Meatball Sub!!!The pizza crust is perfect! The crust is thin, crispy and tastes great!Tony makes this place feel like a real NY pizza joint!I will eat here again.