Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza - East Islip

Okay, we have been to two other restaurants in Farmingdale and Commack and were not impressed. But wow, this place is the best. The service is exceptional. Greg, the manager, made our meal an unforgettable experience. After our last visit, we were hesitant to give this place another chance, but we are so glad we did. This will be the only place we visit from now on. Thank you, Greg, you are a valuable asset to this company without a doubt!

I tried this pizza for the first time tonight using Uber Eats, but unfortunately the delivery was not great. Uber took too long and the pizza arrived cold. However, when I called and spoke to the manager, he was understanding and made sure to send a fresh, hot pizza to my door personally. It was delicious and I will definitely be returning because they made the situation right. Also, the chicken wings were amazing. Thank you for the high-quality service!