Irish Coffee Pub - East Islip

I had the salmon francese, and it was very good! However, I wasn't a fan of the dried onion on top, as it detracted from the moisture of the salmon. Overall, everything else was delicious, and the salmon itself was fantastic!

I had a large gathering at this restaurant, and unfortunately, the prime rib was disappointing—lacking flavor and not up to par. The chicken was also too dry. The highlight of the meal was definitely the spinach crab soup, which was excellent. However, the service was quite slow; I even ended up clearing the glasses off the table myself. On a positive note, the pricing seemed fair.

This restaurant is truly a gem. The interior is beautifully designed, and the food is absolutely delicious. There's a catering room upstairs with an outdoor deck, which adds to the charm. The staff is friendly and attentive, making for a delightful dining experience. We visited on St. Patrick's Day and had a wonderful time, even though it was for a funeral luncheon. Everything was exceptional - the cleanliness, the inviting atmosphere, and the overall quality of service. I would give it five stars across the board!

Whoever pours Guinness here knows how to do it right.

I’ve eaten at the restaurant and also used them as my caterer for my wedding. The Irish Coffee Pub serves delicious food with generous portions both at their restaurant and when catering. I hired them to come to my venue and they took care of everything. They brought their own linens, plates, utensils, etc and also assisted with renting extra tables and chairs as well as set up. The waitstaff made sure that everyone in the bridal party placed their orders prior to the reception grand entrance and personally came up to my husband and I throughout the night to see if we needed a refill or anything. Nobody went home hungry and all of the guests raved about the food. The staff is extremely friendly and organized. While planning and on the wedding day I barely had to do anything because the Irish Coffee Pub had either done it already or thought of it for us. For our guests with dietary restrictions they came up with something custom to serve for us, and ensured that nothing would be cooked with any allergens (we had a guest with severe peanut allergy). I will definitely continue to dine at their restaurant and highly recommend them for catering any event.