Stephanie's Sugar Spice Cafe

Dont forget this bakery.. many choices-cakes, muffins, cookies, streudel , breakfast then lunch items.. I had a Delicious lemon raspberry muffin..one of 1st stores on right- coming into downtown

Love love love this gourmet type deli snack-feast. Everyone's correct the owner is super amazing. I choose the hot ham and cheese side of potato salad and a cheese danish.. YUM YUM . My pictures do not do this place justice. Prices are very very reasonable for the high quality of food you get.

I visited this restaurant with high expectations for their Peanut butter cookies. Unfortunately, I was disappointed to find that the quality of the cookies has declined. They used to be thick and flavorful, but now they are flat and taste like store-bought cookies. The only redeeming factor was a delicious chocolate chip cookie that was freshly baked. Overall, it was a big letdown.

If I could give it more than 5 stars I would! Stephanie could not have been nicer and more accommodating in helping us come up with a menu for our guests.. She prepared food for a welcome lunch for 20 people who came to Fernandina Beach for a 50th birthday celebration. The chicken salad wraps, seafood quiche, caprese salad, pasta salad and dessert tray were ALL delicious. Stephanie delivered all the food on/in real dishes (not plastic). She went above and beyond to make our luncheon special. Everyone thought the food was spectacular. I highly recommend Stephanie 's for a quick lunch or for a catered affair.

I'll begin by saying that the staff at this restaurant is friendly. However, my experience was just okay. Despite high expectations based on the reviews, I was ultimately disappointed. I ordered a slice of chocolate cake with ganache, but unfortunately it was old and stale. The cake was dry and tasted like it had been sitting in the fridge for too long. I'm still on the lookout for a bakery that makes everything from scratch and believes in the importance of freshness.