Cosimo's Pizza - Fort Collins

Cosmo's is an excellent spot for enjoying slices and whole pies. The slices are generously sized and satisfying, and they are served throughout the day.

I had a difficult experience with curbside pick-up when I arrived at the restaurant; they said it was only for special requests or cases. Despite clearly stating on their online ordering system that they offer curbside pick-up, they insisted I come inside. I explained that my family and I are high risk, with my child in tow, and asked if they could bring my order out to me. I even offered to meet them at the door. Ultimately, I met a woman at the door, thanked her, and was then asked if I wanted to add a tip to my card. I found it extremely rude to ask for a tip, especially for a pick-up order where she only had to walk my pizza from the front to the back of the store. Many people choose pick-up to save money, and I had been a satisfied customer of Cosmos for years until this incident. I felt like a burden and the whole situation was awkward. However, on a positive note, the pizza was delicious. I will not be returning to this restaurant.

I visited this restaurant on a Monday around 3 o'clock. It was not very busy. I ordered two slices of pepperoni pizza, but they forgot to heat them up. I had to wait for about 30 minutes. However, I must say that the pizza was delicious and some of the best I have had in Colorado. I even liked it more than Krazy Karl's.

They are so busy because they’re so good. They are well staffed and everyone is patient and kind. Onto the food, I’m from NYC and hands down the best pizza I have had out west. Management is professional and fair as well as prices. 10000/10 recommend.

I just moved after a ride from steamship to Fort Collins and my nephew said go get Cosmos pizza, get the spicy Ranch scuba sauce. Well, I had 10 minutes before they finished, I called to see if they still had discs. And bingo, massive slices, big diving sauce and all nice employees! I have the 32oz drink to keep a souvenir cup out of place. Definitely worth it! The image is the discs from the case, not heated, did not want to stop them during their closing time.. Quarter there to show size comparison.