Pizza Supreme - Garden City

Delicious! They were perfectly cooked and crispy, and arrived hot. This might be one of the best rice balls I've ever tasted.

The size of the slices is large which is good for me and they have so many different toppings.

The best meatballs around! Their unique square pizza is fantastic, along with a variety of other delicious pizza styles and baked dishes. I've been enjoying Pizza Supreme for over 40 years, dating back to when they were located in the mall. - Erik

You haven't truly enjoyed pizza until you've tasted the square pizza from the original creators.

Pizza Supreme used to be situated in Roosevelt Field, close to the Time Out Arcade. Their square pizza was consistently outstanding. There’s nothing quite like a steaming hot square slice topped with incredible mozzarella, flavorful sauce, and a perfectly crispy crust. It really takes you down memory lane. Pizza Supreme is truly a hidden gem.