Shortys Steakhouse - Garrett

Me and my wife went there for our first time on 10/13/23, we both got the 14oz new York strip specials, neither steak had absolutely no seasoning at all, I got well done which was surprisingly cooked right but with the lack of seasoning I just wasn't interested in finishing it, she got medium rare, her steak was extremely tough, so she asked for another and that one was equally as tough and hard to cut through, she said there was alot of fat and grizzle, definitely not a $50 steak, her green beans had absolutely no seasoning, they tasted like they were fresh out of the can, I ordered steak fries, they came out soggy and undercooked, when I asked for new ones they took them away and was back less than three minutes later which made it obvious I did not get new ones, they simply put the first ones back in the fryer, they didn't try to deny it either, this was our honeymoon dinner and now my wife has been up all night and morning throwing up everything she ate last night which means she got food poisoning from something there, I didn't get it because I ate very little because the food was so disappointing, the drinks were good and our waitress Brittany was probably the best waitress I have had in years, they knew they messed up really bad so they didn't want to charge us for anything, I had them charge me for the drinks just so I could tip the waitress because we had no cash, they are a steakhouse yet mostly serve seafood and seafood related items which makes little sense if you're a steakhouse and you mess up extremely bad on the steaks, their prices are way too high for the lack of quality, I imagine their continued patronage is from locals that don't want to travel twenty minutes to a larger town and wait in line, we were there at 8pm and they were completely dead by 9:30 pm with no customers but us and that says something as well

1st time eating here. The food was excellent. I had the almond fried haddock fingers with jalapeño tartar sauce. The brussel sprouts and creamy wild rice were also very good. It is pricey for the dinners. I chose appetizers and specialty sides. Service: Dine in Meal type: Dinner

The prime rib flatbread was amazing! Definitely would order again. Husband got beef tips on noodles. That was delicious as well. Great food and fantastic service. Service: Dine in Meal type: Dinner Price per person: $10–20 Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5 Recommended dishes: Fried Brussel Sprouts

The service was great! The atmosphere was nice. The food was SO not worth the price. You can get a better steak in Fort Wayne for 2/3 the cost, or make your own at home. The salad and potatoes were not flavorful. The presentation was nice and ther server was excellent, but I'd much rather spend my money somewhere else and get a good meal. Service: Dine in

Best prime rib nice place Service: Dine in Meal type: Dinner Price per person: $50–100