carlyle seafood shack - GLEN HEAD

I have always enjoyed this place and I still love the beautiful beach setting. However, this summer, the menu has been reduced to far few choices. Still enjoyed the crab cake and some of the salads. However, the more substantial dishes and sides have been eliminated. I was sorry to see.

We went for dinner tonight to celebrate our anniversary and figured it would be a great night because we came a month ago and all was good. Tonight was a disaster. So many things were terrible it's hard to recap. We weren't given menus, I had to go up to the hostess and get them after waiting for minutes for someone to notice us. My oyster platter came out without horse radish, vinegar, and cocktail sauce so I had to get up again and ask for them. When the bus boy came to collect our dirty plates he took our silverware so I had to get up again to get new forks and knives. Our waitress was MIA the entire night. She never came to check on our drinks. We finished them and never had another round. Nobody came to refill our water. The main courses took an eternity to come out. I told the waitress to just pack up the main courses bc I didn't feel like staying there anymore and she said ok. A few minutes later a different bus boy served them at our table (no communication I began eating, the food was bland as ever and not appealing so I asked someone else to bag it up and then asked someone else for the check. What a disaster. I'm so annoyed. I had a miserable time for a crappy dinner. Thank you for making this anniversary . I'm leaving out so many other annoying parts to the meal bc I think you get the gist.

My wife got sick from the food We will not be returning. Ever!!!

A reservation for a party for Saturday night, but when we arrived in restaurant it was closed, I knew that this was a seasonal facility, but the information on the website was very inaccurate

Carlyle’s seafood shack is a beautiful place. the personal is friendly, the intention is beautiful and very quiet, and the eating and service is always good.