White Buffalo Pub And Pizza Co.

Not bad Service: Take out Meal type: Dinner Price per person: $10–20 Food: 4 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5 Recommended dishes: White Buffalo

The restaurant is super overpriced for what it offers. The waitress took our order, brought the food, and then never came back to check on us. The Chicago hot dog bun was hard and over-seasoned with celery salt. We never received any drink refills as the staff seemed too busy talking to other customers and completely ignored us. The prices were unreasonable, with a 12" pizza costing $21 with no toppings and a 12oz PBR costing $6.50. On a positive note, the waitress did comp the hotdog after we had only taken two bites and had to flag her down to get the check. At the time, there were only 2 other people at a table and 1 person at the bar.

The pizza was served hot, but after discussing with my husband on the way home, we realized that we did not receive the pizza we ordered. It was supposed to have BBQ sauce, but it sounds like we actually got the White Buffalo instead. Despite being exhausted, we didn't mind too much. The Mac and cheese bites seemed to be from a box and were cold. To make matters worse, the appetizer, pizza, and drinks all arrived at the same time because there was only one server handling everything. While the pizza was good, I expected more for the price we paid. Perhaps it tasted better because we were tired. Overall, it was not the worst experience, but I don't think it was worth the price.

The Italian beef sandwich was not good, it seemed like it should be fed to the dog that is always at the restaurant. However, the pizza was tasty. The service was lacking, and the atmosphere was okay. Overall, the meal was not worth the price. Service: 1 Food: 3 Atmosphere: 3 Dine in Lunch $30–50 per person.

The pizza at this restaurant was excellent, with generous toppings and a unique square cut on circular pizzas. Our group of 8 hungry guys, who had skipped golf, ordered 4 pizzas and a couple of appetizers. However, we found that the service was lacking due to the understaffed and inexperienced team. Despite their friendliness, they were quite slow and seemed overwhelmed by the busy night. We had to wait 5 minutes for our to-go boxes and had difficulty getting drinks, even water pitchers. The appetizers arrived after the pizzas and were lukewarm. The pizzas, on the other hand, were outstanding with plenty of toppings and cheese. The Buffalo pizza was especially meaty, while the Homestead pizza had a fantastic BBQ flavor. The double pepperoni and sausage pizzas were delicious, though some thought the sausage could have been more plentiful. Overall, we would rate the pizza 8.5/10 and the service 6/10.