Carey's Restaurant and Pub

This small but charming restaurant pub has good food and good service. Good for families, friends or buds. Try the best wings in Muskoka!

I had the Thai wings that were barrered and my husband had deep fry wings with sauce on the side. Mine were totally fatty and his were cooked so long that they were dry. Very disappointing.

I have to say I don't usually eat in bars and was not sure where I was being taken but when I got there we sat at a bar type table. The waiter came over and he was very respectful and polite. There was music playing and a man singing in the corner. He was really good. Also I wasn't sure what to eat so I had something I don't normally order a quesadilla. It was super good and I ate all four pieces. I was so stuffed but it was so good. The other two I was with had wings and they looked great. They were a good size too. My husband had the cod and he enjoyed that as well. The food was great.

Always went by, never went in until now. Read up on reviews, thought we,d try it. It was busy, but friendly staff found two spots at the bar for us. What is lacking in decor is made up by the talented live music. Sports tv was visual only, no sound. The food was produced in good time, hot, delicious and plenty of it. I had the best liver and onions ever! The potatoes were the real mashed, the veggies el dente, and the liver succulent and tender. My husband had the trout and he too found it to be delicious with the rice done perfectly. Beer was a good price, and it was family friendly too. It is a little crowded, in the winter, but noticed an outdoor patio. Highly recommend it!

Our first impression when we pulled up was to turn around (due to the not so nice looking motel attached to the restaurant) but the reviews said this place was good so we decided to give it a try. Its nothing fancy, but its clean and the staff were great. I had the meatloaf which was a huge portion and delicious! Would eat here again for sure.