Kings New York Pizza - Hagerstown

The best steak and pepperoni in the area! The pickle pizza is incredible as well. I highly recommend this place if you’re looking for authentic New York-style pizza! Food: 5 Service: 5

I’ve dined here three times in the past month, and the quality and flavor have been consistently excellent. The portions are generous. My partner really enjoyed the chicken souvlaki and the steak and cheese. I tried the gyro and the chicken cheesesteak, both of which were great. My mom loved her chicken parmigiana sub. The sub rolls are fresh and robust enough to hold all the filling. Their fries are crispy on the outside and creamy on the inside. I haven't tried the pizza yet, but I'm excited to give it a go!

I ordered the Seafood COMBO and it was absolutely delicious! For dinner, the price was between $10–$20 per person. I would rate the food, service, and atmosphere all at 5 stars. I highly recommend trying the Margarita Pizza, Mussels in Marinara Sauce, and Steak Stromboli. There’s plenty of parking available, and you can take advantage of the free parking lot.

Doordash order was great! Togo containers should be microwavable though. Food is excellent, everything I asked for was included. Great job! Service: Delivery Meal type: Dinner Price per person: $50–100 Food: 5 Service: 4

I want to start by saying that the pizza here has fantastic flavor! The sauce is definitely savory, which suits my taste much better than the odd choice of sweet pizza sauce. The New York-style pizza features a thin and crispy crust, making for an overall delicious pie! My only concern is the use of a lower-grade mozzarella cheese. I've noticed that after the pizza sits for 10 to 15 minutes and the cheese cools, it quickly becomes rubbery in texture. High-quality mozzarella should remain stringy and gooey even after reheating at home. This is why I’m giving this place four stars. If they upgraded to a better cheese, I would gladly give them the fifth star. To the owners, please consider using premium mozzarella, as we’re paying premium prices for the pizza. We would hate to stop visiting because of this issue. On a positive note, the salads here are excellent and come in generous portions. I particularly enjoy the Gyro and the bacon chicken avocado salad. The service is satisfactory. If Kings starts using a better cheese, I will happily give them the fifth star they truly deserve!