All Star Bagel - Hamilton Square

Bagel was not too good, tasted stale and had a weird flavor other than an everything bagel. I did not want to even finish it. The iced coffee was all milk. I’ll be trying other bagel shops.

Honestly. I don’t know how this place is still in business. I’ve had better bagels from the pre packages section in the grocery store. This is New Jersey I thought we perfected the bagel already. The prices are outrageous as well

Bagels stay fresh in plastic bags for a week couldn’t believe it

I’ve ordered many times from All Star and the bagels are always very good and fresh. The sandwiches I order for myself are always excellent. I would give 5 stars if it weren’t for the fact that my husband’s order is consistently made with cheese when he never orders anything with cheese. Perhaps it’s a GrubHub thing, since that’s how I usually order, but there’s no indication on the app that the sandwich comes with cheese, he never selects cheese as an option, and we even leave notes sometimes asking for no cheese. About 70% of the time, though, his sandwich shows up with cheese. It’s just disappointing because when the order is correct, he loves the food.

Had an egg bagel with butter. I liked that I could bite my bagel and butter did not come gushing out of it. Good flavor, nice chew, not overly crusty. Wish they had poppyseed. I will be back.