Black Eyed Susans Tavern

Don't order the Cesar salad. For $17 all you get is a big plate of uncut romaine lettuce. Very disappointing. Pizza was decent, ambiance was great as well as the service.

We ordered takeout. 2 pizzas for 52$. I would like my pizza cooked and maybe some care put into it for that price. The dough was soggy to the point where I couldn't even cut it and the Blanco Verde pizza looked like I took bagged salad that's been sitting out in a hot parking lot in Acme in just threw it on top of semi cooked dough. Thanks

Overpriced small menu nothing special only atmosphere

An evening at Black-eyed Susan is always a wonderful experience! My husband and I live in Surf City year round and often visit Black-eyed Susans for their live music and reliably delicious dinners and cocktails. We got married on the island this July, and were so thrilled to host our rehearsal dinner in the private room upstairs. The space was the perfect size for our family event (24 people), giving us room for three large tables, as well as an acoustic guitarist, a few high tops, and the stylish cocktail bar. Justin the private events coordinator was such a pleasure to work with. He helped us situate all of our decor (linens, florals, signage) and effectively navigate the three-course menu (even with a number of challenging allergies). The food was delicious, as always, and the staff were lovely and attentive. Our guests all spoke so highly of the event. I can't wait for our next visit! (Photos by Ann Coen Photography) Dietary restrictions: Black-eyed Susans happily accommodated for allergies including peanuts (including peanut oil), lentils, peas, fava beans, lobster, mussels, and balsamic vinegar. Even with some of these ingredients in their kitchen they were able to assure no cross-contamination.

Black Eyed Susans never disappoints! Every year it gets better and better from the beautiful outdoor setting and new cocktail caboose, coupled with acoustic music, amazing food and impeccable service. You cannot go wrong. What a gem here in Harvey Cedars!