New York City Pizza

The buffalo chicken pizza is tasty. We also added ricotta cheese. Delicious!

After trying numerous pizza places on the island, we have determined that New York City Pizza is the top choice for consistency and quality. As someone who has enjoyed pizza in New York City multiple times, I can confidently say that NYCP is the closest you can get to the real thing. Whenever we visit the island, we make sure to order a pizza from NYCP.

The pizza was excellent and truly reminiscent of New York-style. I would recommend skipping the Smash Burger as it was not very satisfying. However, the meatball sandwich was exceptional. The service was very good and friendly.

Topping a little skimpy in sliced but we love NYC pizza

I do not recommend the Charleston location of this restaurant. I was very disappointed after my children had been getting pizza from here for years. They did not have our order ready on time due to a "ticket mix-up", and then they gave us the wrong wing order. Despite many staff members being aware of the problem, no one offered an apology. I will not be returning to this establishment.