Tutti Pazzi Italian - Isla de Sanibel

Decided to try this restaurant on Sanibel. The reviews were good but I can’t understand why. As an appetizer we ordered the fried artichokes. They literally tasted like frozen appetizers that were baked. I ordered the grouper and my wife ordered a gluten free pizza. As the dishes were brought to the table you could smell the fish and that it was in its last leg if not already gone. I was horrified. Asked them to take away and I would share the gluten free pizza with my wife. Except it wasnt a gluten free pizza but a regular pizza. Save your money and go to real restaurant on the island like Doc Fords. Where we’ve never had a bad meal….

Best Italian meal my wife and I have had, great service thanks to (Chris)

Late evening dinner after watching the sunset at Captiva. Great service, food had great flavors and presentation. We enjoyed the pizza, chicken Parm, fettuccine Alfredo with grilled chicken and broccolini and a fish stew special of the night. Highly recommended for families And anyone visiting the area. Bonus, Live entertainment!

Best pizza I’ve ever had (and I’ve had a lot of pizza!

Horrible service. Food was over priced and not great.