Peter's Steakhouse - Isleton

The decor definitely doesn’t match the building. The service is seriously incredible . But the rest was mediocre at best. None of the food had any flavor. The bread was cold. If our eyes were closed we wouldn’t have been able to tell what it was. It was all lukewarm. The bathroom was so gross I gagged and walked out. Looks like it’s never been cleaned.

Good piece of Prime Rib bring your own red wine list is poor.

Great food and great ambiance! Prime Rib Dip is the Best!

My prime rib sandwich was very blah and tough. I was very disappointed in our lunch.

I was lured in by the rating and reviews. I made the trek to Isleton solely for the prime rib at Peter’s Steakhouse. But not sure what happened, the prime rib I got was dry and served at a lukewarm temp. Bummer. Service on the other hand was off the charts down right hospitable.Hubs and I dropped in for lunch. I ordered the prime rib sandwich and chose a green salad for my side. Hubs ordered a cheeseburger with fries (which were thick cut). My prime rib was flavorless and dry, lacking that fresh cooked wet juiciness. Plus it was served at a lukewarm temperature. Aw shucks. The salad on the other hand was delicious. Surprisingly it had pumpkin seeds and raisins, nice twist. The blue cheese dressing was disappointing though. It was flavorless as well with a thin, runny consistency. So bizarre. Another odd thing was the temperature inside the restaurant. It was chilly. It didn’t seem to warm up.Speaking about the building, it has quite the history. It was built in 1878 as a mercantile shop. The town’s main wharf and dock was located behind the mercantile. The dock is long gone. Throughout the years, the building served as a post office, Oddfellows Hall, community center … and now Peter’s Steakhouse. There is an info board on the dining room wall with old photos describing the building’s history. The last major remodel was in 2005. The dining room is a mix of Americana steakhouse with Chinese art work.If I happen to be in the area, I might consider giving Peter’s another go.