Duchess Cookies Islip

Nice addition to Islip and the place has potential. I only gave 2 stars because the cookies are way over priced. $5 a cookie?!! And we think they were a bit undercooked. Could use more of a variety and maybe some additional specialties as an additional draw. Will go back to try other cookies, maybe they will add more choices. Different coffees and teas would be a good start.

The cookies are really good and unique, came into the patchogue store after going out for dinner with my husband and son. The cookies were warm and delicious we sat in to eat it but were very thirsty. My only complaint is that for a cookie shop they don’t offer milk to go with it just nesquick water or coffee (only with flavored creamers offered still not milk even for coffee . I think having milk offered as a beverage in a cookie shop is common sense and very strange to not have as an option.

Nice place, nice service. But the cookies were not cooked in the center. Cookies are a nice size for 3.50 each.

Im not one to leave reviews unless I feel it absolutely worth it. I just tried Duchess Cookies on Northampton street in Easton PA today, it’s very clear they are from NY, but the cookies are very good, they are soft and have great taste along with good appearance and not to mention they are a decent size, You pay a little more than in stores but you will not get something like this in a normal store, I will say for a unique cookie that we don’t really have access to in the stores, they definitely get a 5 stars from me. I’m willing to pay a little more for creativity and taste. Give them a try you will not be disappointed.

Cookies are not worth your hype theyre just big cookies but they're okay for a girls scout camp day care.