Maxie's Supper Club Oyster - Ithaca

My companion and I decided to try Maxie's for dinner while in Ithaca yesterday. We were greeted and seated immediately. Our server brought menus and water promptly. We ordered raw clams and raw oysters for appetizer which were served with cocktail sauce, vinegar and grated horseradish. I especially liked the oysters...they were fresh and so smooth. For our meal, I had a half order of Shrimp Grits with a side of Collard Greens. Both dishes were flavorful and delicious! My companion had tuna which he loved. Service was outstanding as well. We will definitely return!!!!

Did not expect such an amazing oyster experience in Ithaca. we went on a saturday night around 530pm, they only had seating at the bar (they had lots of tables and it was a really sad rainy day so they must be popular!!! . the service was amazing and we got to watch the oysters being shucked in front of us! can't imagine having her muscles. they came with FRESH horseradish (which i've never had and YUM it was a slightly spicy, nutty flavor. there were two options of oysters that day in which me and my friend could not tell apart LOL. we said we liked the big ones so for round two the bartender gave us big ones only, so sweet! people sitting at the bar were friendly too. would come back again especially during happy hour 4-5:30pm

Very large portions, good service, vegetarian jambalaya was very good. Fish tacos were ok.

We enjoyed a very good dinner here. We started with raw oysters during Happy Hour! Excellent! We ordered steamed clams, and were similarly pleased. We like to graze and had sides of collard greens and spinach. This was all topped off by a generous slice of Key lime pie.ambiance of Seafood /fish.. "kid and bustling. Service was good and did not rush us. Only negative is limited parking.

I came to Maxie's earlier in the summer and the experience was just as memorable as I expected! Service was excellent, drinks were generous, and food was hot fresh delicious and included a variety of vegetarian options! Would certainly return if in the area.