Eaton Street Seafood Market - Key West

I've found a new favorite place in Key West! The shrimp rolls here are absolutely the best—no contest. They're incredibly fresh and flavorful, lingering in your memory long after you’ve finished. I also tried the conch fritters, and they were simply delicious. I came back the next day just to try the crab cake croissant, and it definitely lived up to my expectations. The outdoor patio was cool and tidy, which is a great advantage given the heat. The staff was friendly, and the service was impressively quick. If you’re in Key West, this is a must-visit! Parking is limited, but there are a few spots available, which is rare for the area.

Everything was fantastic! The retro exterior has a very clean and inviting atmosphere. Inside, it’s comfortably air-conditioned and spotless, though it does carry the natural scent of a seafood market. I'm excited to come back! Food: 5/5

We had lunch at this restaurant, and it was quite decent! The lobster sandwich was good, although a bit overpriced. The tuna sandwich, on the other hand, tasted like it came straight from a can, but I'm not entirely sure. The shrimp taco was really enjoyable, though I wish it had come with three instead of just two. The building itself is charming, clean, and has a unique character. It offers a pleasant atmosphere and a nice ambiance.

Amazing! ! This casual dining restaurant has something for everyone! I had the divinely inspired smoked fish dip with crackers: the dish was to die for! The long drive down to Key West was well worth it having a chance to taste many of their delicious bites! Their portions are very generous indeed! Their fish tacos so fresh and with a creamy sauce that hits all the right notes! And the conch fritters were to die for. Our wonderful server, also brought our kids tummy fries and chicken tenders!This is definitely Key West’s best kept secret especially if you’re a true Seafood lover! Don’t say I didn’t warn you, the seafood here is just par excellence; pure wholesome goodness! Thanks for a wonderful meal!Kid-friendliness: They are so nice and welcoming! My kids loved it!

Amazing! ! This casual dining restaurant has something for everyone! I had the divinely inspired smoked fish dip with crackers: the dish was to die for! The long drive down to Key West was well worth it having a chance to taste many of their delicious bites! Their portions are very generous indeed! Their fish tacos so fresh and with a creamy sauce that hits all the right notes! And the conch fritters were to die for. Our wonderful server, also brought our kids tummy fries and chicken tenders! This is definitely Key West's best kept secret especially if you're a true Seafood lover! Don't say I didn't warn you, the seafood here is just par excellence; pure wholesome goodness! Thanks for a wonderful meal!