The Original Brooklyn Pizza - Lexington

I was very impressed with the customer service, but the garlic bread and pies were slightly underwhelming. Perhaps my expectations were too high as I have heard from numerous people, including friends, that Original Brooklyn has the best pie in town. Although not my favorite, it would likely be in my top five.  <br/ <br/ First, regarding the customer service, I placed a carry out order approximately 25 30 minutes early, and when I arrived, my order had not been entered into the system. The staff was extremely apologetic, started working on my order immediately, and offered me a free beer at the bar while I waited (the bar area is a really nice space to watch a game . Customer service is easy when things go well, but you can really tell how a place treats its patrons when things don't. Based on my positive customer service experience alone, I would visit Original Brooklyn again. <br/ <br/ As for the cuisine, the garlic bread seemed store bought (which was a shame because the marinara sauce was very tasty , and the cheese pizza was simply average. Our favorite item that we ordered was the Buffalo Chicken (with ranch we ordered without jalapenos, which for us, made the pie nicely balanced with the spicy buffalo chicken and the creamy ranch sauce. I do agree with many of the reviewers below that the crust is top notch (perfectly crunchy and thin not overcooked . <br/ <br/ We still prefer Grey Goose, Mellow and Verona, but we will return to try different pies. Also, excluding the bar area, this place could certainly be updated (such as the carpet, paint, etc. .

The pizza is fantabulous, the pickle backs are a must, and the beer choices are on spot!! If you're looking for a great place to catch the game or just catch up with friends, this is a must try!!

Best authentic NY Style pizza in Lex!! Goodfellas comes in 2nd. Only problem I have is the dining room is too dark. Could use pendant lights above each table.

This truly is the best pizza in town! The garlic knots are really good as well. I suggest the pepperoni pizza, the crust is amazing. The service is the best too! Obviously, I can't find any negative thing to say. You must give it a try.

Exactly the way it should be!. Excellent! Finally! Good pizza! We ordered their 19' pepperoni pizza. The crust was perfect and thin, not chewy at all! The cheese they use is of the best quality, and you can taste it! There was just the right amount of sauce too on the lighter side . The pepperonis though! Wow. They were the size of small saucers. Huge, and thinly sliced, like what you would get from a deli. They were not greasy and gross either. Just a perfect touch. We will happily be coming here more often.