Eileen's Colossal Cookies - Liberty

There is no better frosted sugar cookie anywhere, and I would argue with anyone who disagrees. These cookies are simply divine. The buttercream frosting, with just a touch of almond, is utterly indulgent. It’s hard to believe something could taste this amazing. The cookies are affordable, and they somehow manage to produce them in bulk while keeping the quality at its highest. I often stop by to grab a dozen or two for gatherings, and they are always a crowd-pleaser. I found this place when a colleague brought in some, and I've been coming back ever since.

Dear Eileens! We often get their treats for birthdays at work, and my family loves it because it means I can bring home a dozen when I pick them up. Lemon is a family favorite! You can grab a day-old dozen for just $6... yes, really! And their cookies are absolutely amazing.

The staff here is extremely friendly, and the cookies are absolutely delicious! I think the prices are very reasonable, especially if you have the cookie card, which is just $5 and lasts for a year. It's a great way to save a lot of money!

A class act! We ordered a cookie cake for my son's birthday in March of 2020. Of course, Covid happened and the party was canceled. Not only did they keep my credit on file for over a year, but they are giving me full credit on my next order. Their products are delicious and their service is awesome! Thank you!

This is a popular choice for pension recognition at work. Large cookies, easy to order a mixed variety and they will usually deliver when they are able.