Ernie's Ice Cream - Mahwah

This ice cream is absolutely delicious! The coconut flavor is fantastic, and the peanut butter isn't overwhelming at all. It's hands down the best ice cream in town!

I tried the Cookie Monster-flavored ice cream, but there wasn't much cookie dough or cookie pieces in it. It mostly tasted like blue-colored vanilla ice cream. I was a bit disappointed.

The ice cream is fantastic, but I recently ordered three quarts for $55 and was disappointed to find that the top 1.5 inches were empty and there were significant gaps along the sides. This issue isn’t a one-time occurrence; it has been getting worse recently. This experience has pushed me to my limit, and I won’t be ordering from Ernie’s through DoorDash anymore.

Outstanding flavor, exceptional service, and affordable prices. Be sure to grab a cone or two—it’s definitely worth the visit!

Awesome ice cream stand with amazing array of unique and delicious flavors. Lots of soft serve options (mix-in, I believe, but still! . Friendly staff. I had Nutella and Coconut, half and half. Delicious!!!