Western Pizza - Melville

We returned in July, and the waitress recognized us. We immediately heard her say something to the cooks. This time, our food was served hot, our orders were correct, and our dishes were clean. I have ordered pizza a few times since then, and it has been hit or miss—sometimes a bit overcooked, and other times so soggy that it falls apart and is inedible. I used to love this place when I was growing up, and I hope they can figure out the issues and concerns that customers are expressing.

I was served a plate that was visibly dirty, with a coffee stain and what appeared to be grease on it. When I requested a new plate, the waitress, Jackie, brought me one and sarcastically said, "Oh, feel free to inspect the clean one, my god." It was a really disappointing experience, and the food was just average. I wouldn't recommend coming here. I'd give it zero stars if I could.

I usually don’t take the time to leave reviews, but I feel compelled to share my experience. This was honestly the worst pizza I've ever had. I can't believe I spent $75 on two soggy pizzas. The "all meat" pizza was missing several ingredients it was supposed to include, and it cost $40! My kids, who will eat almost any pizza, wouldn't touch it. I strongly advise against going here; it was a terrible experience, and I regret wasting my money.

Worst and most expensive pizza I?ve ever had. 2 large pizzas for $74 is a joke. Soggy greasy crust. Missing ingredients. Just the worst experience. You?re better off with a frozen pizza

Western Pizza used to be one of my favorite dining spots. However, after trying superior fettuccine or poutine elsewhere, their food just doesn't seem to compare anymore.