More Ice Cream - Middletown

Ice cream was delicious, especially the Reese’s parfait. Mr. Jim was incredibly kind and stayed open another ten minutes so we could make it for a sweet treat enjoyed on the lovely front porch.

Stopped here after visiting Crystal Grotto Caverns for an ice cream treat. Staff was friendly and portions were great for the price. Highly recommend banana peanut butter fudge ice cream.

Excellent ice cream!! We are repeat customers with two thumbs up each visit. Several fantastic flavors or sundaes to choose from, you can't go wrong!

Love the small town business. They value the local community as seen by the photos throughout of the local high school athletes. By the way, the ice cream was also delicious..

Super kind and friendly staff. They even let me sample it because it was my first time! Delicious ice cream! Portion sizes are huge and totally worth the money! Definitely will be back!!