South Mountain Creamery - Middletown

This is the best ice cream I've ever had! I tried the salted caramel, while my husband opted for the butter pecan. I highly recommend both flavors. The cows are friendly and clearly accustomed to people. I can't wait to return and sample two more flavors!

Friendly staff and amazing ice cream.. A must if your looking for a nice country drive and some ice cream at the end

The coconut joy was like an almond joy bar and I was pleasantly surprised with the coffee beans in the mocha chip! Worth the drive from I 70.

It was a neat experience. The first time i had ever fed baby cows. The ice cream was delicious. And i even bought a quart of milk. It was much better than the milk in the stores.

Have you ever felt thrilled about receiving gifts, even when you’re the one paying for them? Treating my family to a delightful meal felt like a wonderful gift. I felt confident about the quality of the food and the richness of the ingredients they enjoyed. It was truly fantastic!